In Brief...World News Review: Echoes of an Old German Nightmare: the Weimar Republic

You are here

In Brief...World News Review

Echoes of an Old German Nightmare: the Weimar Republic

Login or Create an Account

With a UCG.org account you will be able to save items to read and study later!

Sign In | Sign Up

×

Niall Ferguson, professor of Political and Financial History at Oxford University, set out a chilling scenario in Britain's Sunday Times (Nov. 24, 2002). His opening words were: "As Chancellor Schröder grapples with a seriously sick economy, he is making the same mistakes which led to the 1930s crisis that opened the door for Hitler."

Just how bad are Berlin's economic woes? In the last decade only Switzerland and Japan had poorer performing economies in the developed world. Further, German unemployment is 8.3 percent of the work force and is predicted to reach one in 10. As an overall assessment The World in 2003 said this: "Germany, once the country of the post-war economic miracle, is acquiring a reputation as the sick man of Europe, with low growth, high unemployment and an unwillingness to contemplate the sort of changes that might get it out of its current difficulties" (published by The Economist).

Comparisons with Germany's old financially disastrous Weimar Republic are rife in the British and European media. "Hidden jobless takes Germany back to the level of the Weimar era," writes Tony Paterson for The Sunday Telegraph from the German capital city (Nov. 24, 2002). He reported that "public fury has spilled into the streets of Berlin with demonstrations of health workers, teachers, builders and lorry [truck] drivers."

Bild (a German newspaper) ran a headline that simply said, "We've Had Enough," expressing the frayed emotions of the unemployed. Part of the problem is high wages. Actually, "Britain's hourly labour costs are 30% lower than they are in Germany" (The World in 2003).

The Guardian's correspondent in Berlin reported that the "German tax rise evokes Weimar comparison." Another Guardian headline tells us that "Europe's Most Powerful Banking Sector Is on Red Alert—German Money Machine Grinds to a Halt." The Mail on Sunday also calls Germany the "sick man of Europe"—talking of "debts, dole queues [lines] and industry in crisis."

In reality, conditions are nowhere near as bad as the skyrocketing inflation that plagued the Weimar Republic in the late 1920s and early 1930s when the proverbial wheelbarrow full of marks would not buy so much as a pound of butter. Nonetheless, the Germany economy bears close watching. Hitler's Third Reich emerged out of very grave economic frustrations.

—Sources: The Sunday Times, The Sunday Telegraph, The World in 2003, The Guardian, The Mail on Sunday [all London].