Hannah: a Case Study in Giving Thanks (Part 1)

You are here


a Case Study in Giving Thanks (Part 1)

Login or Create an Account

With a UCG.org account you will be able to save items to read and study later!

Sign In | Sign Up


Hannah was the mother of Samuel - one of Israel's greatest prophets - and his birth was a direct answer to her prayers. With Thanksgiving approaching, let's consider her story as a case study on the proper attitude and spirit of thankfulness. In this first post, I'll analyze Hannah's condition and mindset prior to Samuel's birth.

Hannah was married to a man named Elkanah, who had another wife named Penninah. In that time, having children was considered an enormous blessing, and men tended to (wrongly) give more or less value to their wife depending on the number and gender of her children. In a case such as Elkanah, when a man had more than one wife, this often led to terrible conflict between the wives as they would compete for dominance. Recall the dramatic struggle that this caused between Rachel and Leah in Genesis 29-30!

Hannah was barren (prior to Samuel's birth), but Penninah had several sons and daughters. The temple had not yet been built, so Israel worshiped at the tabernacle in Shiloh, where Elkanah and his family traveled yearly to celebrate the Holy Days and to make offerings, as God commanded (Deuteronomy 16:16 Deuteronomy 16:16Three times in a year shall all your males appear before the LORD your God in the place which he shall choose; in the feast of unleavened bread, and in the feast of weeks, and in the feast of tabernacles: and they shall not appear before the LORD empty:
American King James Version×
). Elkanah provided portions to his wives and all of his (i.e. Penninah's) children to give as offerings (1 Samuel 1:4 1 Samuel 1:4And when the time was that Elkanah offered, he gave to Peninnah his wife, and to all her sons and her daughters, portions:
American King James Version×
). He thoughtfully made sure to give Hannah an extra large offering in order to show her that he still loved and valued her as much as he did Penninah, even though she had no children (1 Samuel 1:5 1 Samuel 1:5But to Hannah he gave a worthy portion; for he loved Hannah: but the LORD had shut up her womb.
American King James Version×
). However, this kind gesture was no match for Penninah's tactics: 1 Samuel 1:6 1 Samuel 1:6And her adversary also provoked her sore, for to make her fret, because the LORD had shut up her womb.
American King James Version×
says that Penninah "provoked [Hannah] severely, to make her miserable, because the LORD had closed her womb." As if being barren wasn't shameful enough, Penninah really rubbed it in! Facing ridicule on such a sensitive subject, it's no wonder that Hannah spent much of her time in Shiloh each year crying, unable to even eat because of Penninah's gloating (1 Samuel 1:8 1 Samuel 1:8Then said Elkanah her husband to her, Hannah, why weep you? and why eat you not? and why is your heart grieved? am not I better to you than ten sons?
American King James Version×

These annual offerings were intended to be an expression of thankfulness for God's blessings throughout the year. Instead, Penninah used it as an opportunity to boast about the children she had birthed rather than expressing sincere gratitude to God for the children He had given her! Penninah clearly missed the mark, not only by her poor treatment of Hannah, but also by taking pride in what she had without giving due credit to God - if she had truly credited God for her children, she would have known better than to brag at Hannah's expense!

How did Hannah view those times of giving offerings? Wouldn't that kind of negativity eventually discourage her from wanting to make the trip to Shiloh? Astoundingly, even with the looming stigma of Penninah's merciless glorying, there is no record of Hannah being reluctant to go before God to give offerings! Instead, she trusted in God and faithfully gave thanks each year without bitterness towards Him. Hannah's attitude is certainly the attitude that we ought to have before God: neither blaming Him for our problems, nor being reluctant to give thanks because of the seemingly greater blessings of others, but humbly acknowledging that He has supplied our every need and continuing to trust in Him to provide as He sees fit!

This Thanksgiving, make sure that you aren't merely enjoying what God has given you or discouraging others by flaunting your abundance, as Penninah did. Instead, emulate Hannah's attitude: be humble, thankful, and prayerful before God!

Be on the watch for my next blog post, in which I'll focus on Hannah's prayer for a child. I'll demonstrate by Hannah's example what our attitudes should be like when asking for blessings, whatever our specific needs may be.